The Pridwin Hotel And Cottages
Rialto Score 9+Preferred · 81 Shore Rd
Destinations · United States
The Full List of Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, NY with VIP Programs, Ranked (2026)
There are 1 Shelter Island hotel offering VIP programs with additional benefits, such as daily breakfast, hotel credits, and upgrades. Hotels are ranked by Rialto Score which combines thousands of data points and signals. Updated September 8, 2026.
1
hotel ranked
0
with Michelin Keys
0
recommended by Forbes
0
have additional offers